Founding methodology / Version 0.1

Football Intelligence
Framework

A proposed organizational intelligence methodology for CMOs, CEOs and leadership teams at clubs, federations and leagues—connecting commercial, sporting, human and digital capability.

Working methodology · open for expert consultation and pilot validation. We assess organizational capability, not the sophistication of a technology purchase. The weights, scoring anchors and maturity thresholds are provisional.

Explore the model visually.

Demonstration only: invented inputs, not a club score, ranking or certification. Each slider is an average of four indicators. Actual assessments require verified evidence, independent review and the qualification checks in the methodology.

One institution. A connected research system.

01 / Institution

FootballIntelligence.IO

Independent football research and strategic intelligence, with a separately disclosed executive advisory practice.

02 / Methodology

Football Intelligence Framework

A consistent proposed method for evaluating organizational intelligence capabilities.

03 / Measurement

Football Intelligence Index

A proposed 0–100 evidence-based assessment, with maturity profiles and contextual benchmarking only when comparable evidence supports it.

Seven dimensions.
One connected organization.

Proposed weights total 100%. Each dimension contains four indicators: 28 in all. A small club should be able to demonstrate excellent decision maturity without purchasing the technology stack of a global club.

01

Leadership, Strategy & GovernanceOwnership, decisions and accountability · Open to view four indicators

15%
Leadership, Strategy & Governance indicators
CodeIndicatorWhat must be established
G1Strategic alignmentDocumented priorities and accountable owners
G2Decision governanceRights, escalation and approval procedures
G3Investment disciplineBusiness cases and post-investment reviews
G4Organizational learningDecisions reviewed and improvements tracked
02

Data Architecture & InteroperabilityConnected, reliable and governed information · Open to view four indicators

15%
Data Architecture & Interoperability indicators
CodeIndicatorWhat must be established
D1Data qualityCompleteness, accuracy and timeliness controls
D2IntegrationReliable exchange across relevant systems
D3Data stewardshipOwnership, permissions and data lifecycle
D4AccessibilityAuthorized decision-makers access usable information
03

Sporting & Performance IntelligenceCoaching, training and tactical decisions · Open to view four indicators

20%
Sporting & Performance Intelligence indicators
CodeIndicatorWhat must be established
S1Performance workflowsConsistent evidence-led performance processes
S2Training load intelligenceContextual load monitoring and interpretation
S3Tactical intelligenceAnalysis integrated into coaching decisions
S4Outcome evaluationSporting interventions reviewed against objectives
04

Medical & Player Welfare IntelligenceSafeguarding, care and multidisciplinary decisions · Open to view four indicators

15%
Medical & Player Welfare Intelligence indicators
CodeIndicatorWhat must be established
M1Welfare governanceDocumented player welfare safeguards
M2Medical coordinationDefined multidisciplinary communication
M3Return-to-play processIndividualized, accountable return-to-play decisions
M4Health data protectionPrivacy, security and appropriate access controls
05

Recruitment, Academy & Squad IntelligenceTalent identification and long-term squad value · Open to view four indicators

15%
Recruitment, Academy & Squad Intelligence indicators
CodeIndicatorWhat must be established
R1Recruitment methodologyConsistent scouting and evaluation criteria
R2Squad planningScenario-based medium-term squad planning
R3Academy developmentTracked player progression and pathway decisions
R4Recruitment evaluationDecisions reviewed against subsequent outcomes
06

Commercial & Fan IntelligenceAudience understanding and commercial outcomes · Open to view four indicators

10%
Commercial & Fan Intelligence indicators
CodeIndicatorWhat must be established
C1Audience intelligenceConsent-aware audience understanding
C2Fan engagementEngagement measured beyond matchday
C3Commercial performancePartnership and revenue effectiveness
C4Digital ecosystemCoordinated channels and experiences
07

AI & Organizational TransformationEffective adoption, automation and oversight · Open to view four indicators

10%
AI & Organizational Transformation indicators
CodeIndicatorWhat must be established
A1AI governanceOversight, accountability and risk management
A2AI use-case validationDocumented purpose and measured usefulness
A3Workforce adoptionTraining and responsible workflow integration
A4Operational impactVerified time, quality or resource improvements

The evidence behind a score.

Indicator rubric: scores from 0 to 4
ScoreAssessmentEvidence requirement
0AbsentVerified absence of a defined capability or process
1Ad hocPractices exist but are informal or inconsistent
2DefinedDocumented, repeatable process with clear ownership
3IntegratedEmbedded across relevant workflows with monitoring
4OptimizedSustained evidence of effective outcomes and continuous improvement
Proposed evidence classes
ClassSource typeVerification strength
AIndependently verified records or audited outcomesHighest
BReviewed internal documents, system records and corroborated operating evidenceStrong
CStructured practitioner interviews and unverified documentationLimited
DUncorroborated self-report or marketing assertionInsufficient alone

Unverified is not zero. An indicator with missing evidence is marked Not Assessed.

Read the calculation and coverage rules →

Download the proposed 28-indicator inventory (CSV) →

Research integrity charter.

Scores reflect verified operating practices, not technology spend or a preferred vendor. Evaluation must consider organizational scale and context.

A score of 4 requires strong outcome evidence (A or B) over an appropriate review period. Interview testimony alone cannot establish top maturity.

Every indicator must include a date, source category, reviewer and evidence rationale. Missing evidence is Not Assessed, never automatically zero.

A preliminary overall score requires at least 80% weighted evidence coverage and all seven dimensions represented. A verified public assessment requires 100% coverage or formally documented exclusions, plus independent review.

Reports must show missing evidence and a High, Moderate or Limited confidence label based on strength, recency, coverage and review quality. Confidence anchors remain to be calibrated.

Commercial relationships must not determine findings. Material conflicts require disclosure, reviewer recusal where appropriate and independent review.

Serious unresolved welfare, privacy or governance failures trigger qualification review and can block the Adaptive classification regardless of the numerical score.

Before any public rankings, establish assessment eligibility, independent review, corrections and a formal appeals process. These operational procedures are part of the development roadmap, not a claim of existing certification.

This founding methodology is proposed, not an externally certified or industry-validated standard. No club or supplier rankings are published.

Make the process repeatable.

The next instrument is Methodology v1.0, published as a development draft. It retains seven dimensions and 28 indicators and specifies scope, evidence records, assessment controls, review, disclosure and reporting. It does not replace pilot validation with a version label.

Validation comes before ranking.

0.1 / Foundation

Proposed methodology

Seven dimensions, 28 indicators, evidence classes and provisional assessment architecture. This publication.

0.2 / Instrument

Develop the assessment

Question-level scoring anchors, evidence templates, reviewer workflows, report design and confidential-data safeguards.

0.5 / Pilot

Test the method

Independent specialists and a diverse cohort would test inter-rater consistency, indicator usefulness, burden and weighting.

1.0 / Future release

Publish what validation supports

Formal assessments and longitudinal benchmarking follow validation. Public rankings require meaningful comparable evidence.

A method that can be challenged.

Structured evaluation and responsible AI governance provide useful context. NIST’s AI Risk Management Framework organizes risk work around governing, mapping, measuring and managing. It does not validate or certify this football methodology.

Read the NIST AI RMF Core →

The existing seven intelligences discussion framework remains available as a qualitative lens for convenings. These seven assessment dimensions are a separate proposed measurement structure.

Help shape the founding research.

We invite a small founding group of clubs, federations and independent specialists to express interest in consultation or a future pilot. Participation is subject to agreed scope, permissions, confidentiality and conflict review. No assessment, certification, ranking or result is promised at this stage. Paid advisory relationships involving any assessed organization must be disclosed and managed separately from research conclusions. Evidence submission and confidential assessment workflows are not open on this website.

Use the contact details on our About page. Please begin with a general enquiry; do not send player records, confidential documents or proprietary strategies.