Research standards / Version 1.0 · 29 October 2026

Authority needs
accountability.

Our publishing rules, evidence boundaries and route for challenging the record. These standards describe the current operating approach and the requirements for future assessments.

Current review status: Christopher Roselli is the founder and responsible editor. There is no standing independent analyst panel or completed externally validated Index. Independent review is a requirement for future verified assessments, not a credential already held.

Evidence before conclusions.

Every new research briefing must identify its author or responsible editor, publication date, source links, scope, evidence type and material interests. Supplier statements, club announcements, peer-reviewed findings, interpretation and new empirical research must be distinguished. A partnership is not proof of deployment; deployment is not proof of impact.

Public-source summaries must preserve the population, period, units and limitations of the source. Missing public evidence means not documented here, rather than absent. AI-assisted discovery requires original-source checking before a result becomes an editorial finding.

Editorial and commercial boundaries.

Any separately disclosed advisory work remains outside Observatory research. Any paid advisory relationship involving an organization being assessed must be disclosed with the assessment; its scope and dates must be recorded. A materially conflicted assessor must recuse themselves, and an independently reviewed assessment cannot be published until an appropriately independent reviewer is documented. Payment does not purchase placement, favourable coverage, a score or suppression of criticism. No sponsored placement is currently offered in comparative results. Any future sponsored material must be labelled and excluded from independent comparative conclusions.

Founder interests are recorded in the register of interests. For a materially interested supplier, we may describe attributed public capabilities with a prominent disclosure; we must not present a founder-authored rating or recommendation as independent. The founder must recuse himself from an evaluative score or comparative conclusion about that supplier. Until an appropriately independent reviewer is appointed and documented, such an assessment must remain unpublished.

Reviewers must declare relevant employment, ownership, advisory and financial relationships. A client or vendor may point out factual errors but cannot approve editorial conclusions. Confidential advisory information is excluded from public research unless explicit publication permission and an appropriate research basis have been established.

What review must establish.

An editorial synthesis is not an independent peer-reviewed study. A future assessment labelled independently reviewed must name the reviewer, declare interests, document evidence checks and state its review date and limitations. Framework weights and thresholds require pilot testing, agreement checks between assessors and sensitivity analysis before public rankings.

The current simulator, needs matching and public AI research are discovery tools. Their illustrative or provisional outputs do not become verified ratings through publication. No club, supplier or purchaser is certified by this website.

Challenge a finding.

Email footballintelligence.room@gmail.com with the page URL, disputed statement and supporting source. Corrections are reviewed by the responsible editor; no guaranteed resolution time is asserted. A material correction must retain the original publication date and add a dated explanation of what changed. A substantive disagreement should be labelled as such rather than silently rewritten.

If a dispute concerns the founder’s interest, publication of an evaluative conclusion must pause pending independent review. An independent appeals body has not yet been established; the founder’s own review must not be described as independent arbitration.

What is published, and what comes next.

The research hub links published editorial briefings, the existing source library and an initial Technology Landscape. The next empirical phase is a scoped practitioner interview programme with agreed consent, a documented sample, consistent questions and transparent limitations. Future editions should state what changed and which findings remain unresolved.

These standards can support credible research; they do not establish market leadership, universal coverage or equivalence to any other analyst institution.