Football Intelligence Index / Methodology v1.0 — development draft

A method that
can be examined.

Seven dimensions. Twenty-eight indicators. A repeatable proposed process for examining how a football organization turns information into accountable decisions.

Founding research phase · Published 29 October 2026. This is an assessment-instrument development draft, building on the published Framework v0.1. The v1.0 label is a document target, not a claim that pilot validation is complete. No independently validated Index, certification or public rankings are issued.

What the Index proposes to examine.

The proposed unit of assessment is organizational capability: governance, usable information, sporting and medical workflows, recruitment, commercial relationships and responsible AI adoption. Buying a product or signing a partnership is not itself evidence of mature practice.

The model retains the seven dimensions and 28 indicators confirmed for this development phase. Its provisional weights are 15% governance, 15% data, 20% sporting, 15% medical, 15% recruitment, 10% commercial and 10% AI. Neither these weights nor the maturity thresholds have established predictive validity.

A repeatable assessment sequence.

01 / Scope

Define the organization and decision context.

Record the legal/operating entity, teams or venues in scope, assessment period, intended use, relevant scale and exclusions. Agree the sampling plan and evidence cut-off before assessing results.

02 / Interests

Check relationships before accepting evidence.

Record paid advisory, ownership, employment and other relevant interests for the organization and assessors. Disclose paid assessment-related relationships. Recuse material conflicts and document an appropriately independent reviewer before any independently reviewed publication.

03 / Evidence

Build a traceable evidence register.

For every indicator, record source, date, scope, permissions, evidence class, sample denominator, limitations and accountable owner. Request only necessary information through an agreed secure process; public website forms are not evidence-upload channels.

04 / Assessment

Apply the rubric consistently.

Use the measurement specifications as observable checks. Examine quality, repeatability, integration and outcomes against the 0–4 anchors. Record a score rationale or Not Assessed. A high percentage does not automatically establish high maturity.

05 / Review

Challenge the rationale and resolve disagreements.

Use a second appropriately independent assessor for a future verified public assessment. Record initial judgments, disagreements, resolutions and remaining uncertainty. Pilot assessor agreement and evidence burden before treating the instrument as stable.

06 / Calculation

Show coverage before any headline result.

Apply the published v0.1 weighting and coverage rules. Keep missing evidence visible; never replace it with zero. Label partial or unvalidated results accordingly. A simulation is not an organizational assessment.

07 / Reporting

Publish only what the evidence permits.

State scope, dates, version, dimension profile, evidence coverage, confidence rationale, missing information, interests and review status. Separate facts, interpretation and recommendations. No public rankings during the founding research phase.

08 / Learning

Correct and reassess against a stable record.

Provide a factual challenge route, retain dated material corrections and agree an appropriate reassessment point. Explain version changes and rebaseline comparisons when the scope, sampling or instrument changes.

Twenty-eight observable checks.

For each share-based measure, define eligible records, sampling period, numerator, denominator and acceptance checks in advance. Report the sample size and selection method; no convenient sample should be presented as a complete organizational census. A proportion is a process observation, not a validated maturity threshold or proof of impact. If no eligible records exist or the denominator cannot be established, record Not Assessed with a reason; do not invent a percentage.

Where the measure does not fit the organization, document the rationale and review the scope rather than inventing data. Medical and player-related checks require qualified oversight and appropriately redacted assurance; the website should not collect player records.

G

Leadership, Strategy & Governance15% proposed weight · four indicators

+
Leadership, Strategy & Governance measurement specifications
IndicatorProposed observable measurePotential evidence
G1 / Strategic alignmentShare of sampled initiatives with a documented link to an approved priority and a named accountable owner.Approved strategy, initiative register and ownership records.
G2 / Decision governanceShare of sampled material decisions with recorded decision rights, approval and escalation route.Decision log, delegated authority and committee terms.
G3 / Investment disciplineShare of sampled investments with a baseline, full-cost business case and scheduled outcome review.Business cases, cost assumptions and review calendar.
G4 / Organizational learningShare of due decision reviews completed with documented lessons and tracked follow-up actions.Review records and action register.
D

Data Architecture & Interoperability15% proposed weight · four indicators

+
Data Architecture & Interoperability measurement specifications
IndicatorProposed observable measurePotential evidence
D1 / Data qualityShare of sampled critical data fields passing the agreed completeness, accuracy and timeliness checks.Data dictionary, validation results and quality issue log.
D2 / IntegrationShare of required sampled exchanges passing the agreed reliability and reconciliation test.Integration inventory, test results and exception logs.
D3 / Data stewardshipShare of sampled critical datasets with a named steward, defined permissions and lifecycle rules.Dataset register, access rules and retention documentation.
D4 / AccessibilityShare of sampled authorized users able to obtain the required information within the agreed decision window.Role-based task checks, access records and user walkthroughs.
S

Sporting & Performance Intelligence20% proposed weight · four indicators

+
Sporting & Performance Intelligence measurement specifications
IndicatorProposed observable measurePotential evidence
S1 / Performance workflowsShare of sampled coaching decisions with a repeatable evidence-input and review workflow.Workflow documentation and dated decision examples.
S2 / Training load intelligenceShare of sampled sessions where relevant load information was contextualized and reviewed by responsible practitioners.Session records, interpretation notes and practitioner review.
S3 / Tactical intelligenceShare of sampled tactical reviews with a documented link from analysis to a coaching decision.Analysis records and coaching review notes.
S4 / Outcome evaluationShare of due sporting-intervention reviews completed against predefined objectives and limitations.Intervention plans, baselines and review records.
M

Medical & Player Welfare Intelligence15% proposed weight · four indicators

+
Medical & Player Welfare Intelligence measurement specifications
IndicatorProposed observable measurePotential evidence
M1 / Welfare governanceShare of sampled applicable welfare safeguards with a named owner, current procedure and review evidence.Safeguarding procedures and appropriately redacted assurance records.
M2 / Medical coordinationShare of sampled relevant care workflows with documented multidisciplinary responsibilities and handover rules.Workflow protocols and redacted coordination assurance records.
M3 / Return-to-play processShare of sampled eligible return-to-play decisions following the documented individualized, accountable review process.Qualified-clinician assurance and redacted process checks; no public medical records.
M4 / Health data protectionShare of sampled health-data systems passing agreed access, lifecycle and accountability controls.Redacted access-review and data-protection control evidence.
R

Recruitment, Academy & Squad Intelligence15% proposed weight · four indicators

+
Recruitment, Academy & Squad Intelligence measurement specifications
IndicatorProposed observable measurePotential evidence
R1 / Recruitment methodologyShare of sampled recruitment evaluations applying documented, consistent and contextualized criteria.Scouting rubric and redacted evaluation records.
R2 / Squad planningShare of sampled squad-planning decisions supported by dated scenarios, assumptions and ownership.Redacted scenario plans and decision records.
R3 / Academy developmentShare of sampled eligible academy pathways with documented development objectives and progress reviews.Redacted pathway plans and review completion records.
R4 / Recruitment evaluationShare of due recruitment-decision reviews completed against the original rationale and subsequent evidence.Redacted original evaluations and follow-up reviews.
C

Commercial & Fan Intelligence10% proposed weight · four indicators

+
Commercial & Fan Intelligence measurement specifications
IndicatorProposed observable measurePotential evidence
C1 / Audience intelligenceShare of sampled audience segments with a documented purpose, appropriate permission basis and current useful information.Audience definitions, consent or other applicable permission records and quality checks.
C2 / Fan engagementShare of sampled engagement initiatives with a defined supporter need, participation measure and review beyond a single matchday.Experience plans, participation definitions and dated review records.
C3 / Commercial performanceShare of sampled commercial initiatives with defined contribution measures, delivery costs and a completed or scheduled review.Redacted commercial plans, cost records and outcome reviews.
C4 / Digital ecosystemShare of sampled priority supporter journeys with accountable ownership and tested coordination between relevant channels.Journey maps, integration checks and service ownership.
A

AI & Organizational Transformation10% proposed weight · four indicators

+
AI & Organizational Transformation measurement specifications
IndicatorProposed observable measurePotential evidence
A1 / AI governanceShare of sampled AI uses with a named owner, documented risk review and human oversight.AI inventory, risk records and oversight procedures.
A2 / AI use-case validationShare of sampled AI uses with a stated purpose, relevant baseline and an appropriate usefulness test.Use-case documentation and validation results.
A3 / Workforce adoptionShare of sampled affected roles with relevant training, workflow guidance and an adoption feedback route.Training records, task walkthroughs and feedback logs.
A4 / Operational impactShare of due AI or automation reviews evaluating time, quality or resource effects against a baseline.Predefined measures, operational records and limitations review.

Evidence and judgment remain distinct.

Proposed indicator maturity rubric
ScoreAnchorProposed meaning
0AbsentVerified absence of a defined capability or process
1Ad hocPractices exist but are informal or inconsistent
2DefinedDocumented, repeatable process with clear ownership
3IntegratedEmbedded across relevant workflows with monitoring
4OptimizedSustained evidence of effective outcomes and continuous improvement
Proposed evidence classes
ClassEvidence categoryRelative strength
AIndependently verified records or audited outcomesHighest
BReviewed internal documents, system records and corroborated operating evidenceStrong
CStructured practitioner interviews and unverified documentationLimited
DUncorroborated self-report or marketing assertionInsufficient alone

Strong scores require appropriate corroboration and sustained outcome evidence. Missing or inaccessible evidence is Not Assessed, not zero. Measurement specifications above do not replace indicator-specific calibration during pilots.

Calculation is transparent; validation is still required.

With all indicators assessed, a dimension score is the mean of its four 0–4 indicator scores. The proposed overall score is the sum of each dimension score divided by four and multiplied by its percentage weight. The maximum is 100.

For partial evidence, each indicator carries one quarter of its dimension weight. Weighted coverage is the sum of assessed indicator weights. For an incomplete dimension, the observed dimension score uses the mean of its assessed indicators. Any preliminary overall result retains the published dimension weights, must be labelled partial, show coverage and include all seven dimensions. Missing indicators can change that estimate; it is not equivalent to a complete assessment. The existing proposal requires at least 80% weighted coverage for a preliminary overall result.

A future verified public assessment requires 100% coverage or formally documented exclusions, independent review and explicit limitations. Those conditions are proposed gates, not evidence that current results are validated. Read the published calculation rules →

Test before a final release.

A small founding cohort should test whether the indicators can be evidenced consistently across different organizational sizes and contexts. Pilot work should record assessor agreement, unclear judgments, evidence burden, missingness, sensitivity to weights and whether findings are useful to the decision-makers involved.

Review the instrument with independent specialists and publish what changes before issuing a final methodology. Public rankings remain on hold until eligibility, comparability, evidence coverage, conflict controls, review and an appropriate appeals process have been tested.

No target sample, validation outcome or pilot completion is asserted in this draft.

Help develop the method.

Clubs, federations, researchers and independent specialists can express interest in the founding research phase. Begin with the organization, your role and the part of the method you would like to test. Participation is subject to agreed scope and permissions; do not send confidential assessment evidence through public forms.

Responsible editor: Christopher Roselli, founder of FootballIntelligence.IO. Material corrections and research enquiries: footballintelligence.room@gmail.com. Research standards · Register of interests.