03 / Proposed methodology

The Football Intelligence Index

Seven dimensions. A transparent proposal for expert review.

Christopher Roselli · Published 29 October 2026 · Proposed methodology explainer · Version 1.0

A proposal to test, not a league table.

The Football Intelligence Index proposes examining organizational capability across seven connected dimensions. It asks how information, judgment and accountability support decisions across the football organization.

Version 0.1 contains 28 indicators, four per dimension. Weights, scoring anchors and maturity labels are provisional. The interactive simulation demonstrates the arithmetic; it does not assess a real club.

Proposed v0.1 weights. These sum to 100%; they are not empirically calibrated.
DimensionProposed weight
Leadership, Strategy & Governance15%
Data Architecture & Interoperability15%
Sporting & Performance Intelligence20%
Medical & Player Welfare Intelligence15%
Recruitment, Academy & Squad Intelligence15%
Commercial & Fan Intelligence10%
AI & Organizational Transformation10%

What must happen before a verified assessment.

Evidence should be dated, attributable and reviewed against each indicator. Missing evidence is Not Assessed, never automatically zero. A score should communicate coverage and uncertainty rather than disguise them.

The proposed method requires pilot organizations, conflict-screened assessors, checks on agreement between assessors and sensitivity testing of weights and thresholds. A future verified public assessment requires the coverage and independent-review conditions stated in the full methodology. Those procedures have not yet produced validated public rankings.

We invite researchers and practitioners to challenge the dimensions, suggest better indicators and express interest in a scoped pilot. Participation does not imply endorsement, certification or a promised public score.

Scope, interests and the next conversation.

This is an explanation of the publisher’s proposed v0.1 method, not a validated assessment standard. Christopher Roselli is the responsible author and editor; independent external review has not been completed. See the register of interests and research standards and corrections process.

For research or corrections: footballintelligence.room@gmail.com.